Old insulation was some sort of cellulose powder. Not particularly good and very dusty.
The layer of R11 on top of it was definitely not good enough for Colorado.
I removed all of it, bagged everything and vacuumed.
Added some nice R15 / R19 between the joist and about thirty OSB boards so I could walk everywhere.
Finally, added a second layer of R30 insulation on top of everything. Voilà!